I’m pretty close to being done with the whole healthcare thing. I can’t promise I will never write about healthcare again but I honestly don’t see any more movement coming.
For the record I prefer a total government take over of healthcare overnight making it single payer and not for profit. Whether or not the actual government runs healthcare or is administered by a non-profit corporation can be determined. I do believe doctors, nurses, and staff should be paid well.
But we all know this will never happen so the next step down would be a “public option”. This would not be a government takeover of anything. Rather, when you went to buy your insurance you would have an option to buy a government administered plan if you so choose. In theory it would be cheaper than other insurance with adequate care. At this point we don’t know if a public option will be in the final healthcare bill but odds have been steadily improving. Next to the public option would be lowering the Medicare eligibility age or making Medicare available to everyone as a single payer plan.
I think we know where Tea Baggers, Republicans, and Conservatives stand. They are against any government involvement in healthcare. They like things the way they are now with huge profitable insurance companies making billions of dollars in profit who then contribute to political campaigns to ensure government doesn’t try to regulate them.
There are two reasons why Republicans are opposing healthcare. The first one is political. They fear if healthcare reform is passed it will be seen as a victory for Obama. Republicans have made it clear they want Obama to fail because they think if he fails then they think they will sweep the 2010 and 2012 elections. To that end Republicans in the Senate have been filibustering every piece of legislation that comes up for a vote. They also have their brain eating Tea Bagger zombies blogging and twittering every minute that anything Obama wants must be blocked. We saw what they said about Scott Brown when he dared to vote to end the filibuster on the limited jobs bill.
The second reason Republicans oppose healthcare is philosophical. They don’t believe in government. Ever since the Reagan Revolution they have been trying to break government. They have been trying to deregulate and bankrupt the government every chance they get. They do this by blowing all our tax dollars on pie in the sky weapons systems while engaging in unnecessary military operations and simultaneously cutting taxes on the wealthy elite. The increased expenditures coupled with tax cuts leads to massive deficits. This in turn creates the need to cut entitlement programs which is the ultimate Republican goal – to scrap Social Security and Medicare.
Republicans represent the wealthy elite in this country. As such they continually advocate for the wealthy elite and huge corporations to get even more tax cuts. They despise the notion that the wealthy should pay taxes which are used to fund things like education, Social Security, and Medicare. Thus, the idea of creating yet another entitlement program such as Universal Healthcare is an anethema to them. Another entitlement would decrease the possibility of enacting yet another tax cut for the wealthy.
Even though the current proposed healthcare reform legislation is not Universal Healthcare nor is it single payer Republicans still oppose it. They oppose it because they fear over time if it is popular with the public that eventually all for-profit insurance companies will be phased out. The health insurance industry fears this as well which is why they spend hundreds of millions lobbying Congress (both Democrats and Republicans) to prevent any wide sweeping legislation from passing.
Republicans tell us healthcare reform will destroy the country. My question has always been if they think it’s such a bad idea and that it will fail then why not let it pass? After all, if it is a failure the American People will reject it, vote in Republicans, who then can repeal it. They are not concerned healthcare reform will destroy the country as much as they are concerned it will be popular thus helping Democrats gain ground in 2010 and 2012 as well as cementing Obama’s re-election.
Democrats for their part are also heavily lobbied by the health insurance industry which is why if any sort of reform passes at all it will be implemented slowly. The exchanges won’t be up until 2013 and if the public option is included only those without insurance will be able to buy it. The fear moderate Democrats have is causing too much disruption in the system. They fear putting too many people out of work too fast in the health insurance industry. And think what it would do to WellPoint’s stock price let alone the multi million dollar bonuses and salaries for their executives.
As far as Republicans, Conservative, and Tea Baggers go I really question their claim that “the private sector can do things better than government thus we should just leave well enough alone” meme. They claim to love the free market and capitalism. Yet, in the early 2000’s the Bush Administration under Donald Rumsfeld’s direction sought to privatize our military as much as possible. Instead of having our soldiers protect our embassies and State Department employees that job was outsourced to private military contractors. Instead of our military hauling their own supplies, cooking their own food, and building their own bases it was all outsourced. We were told the private sector could perform the same tasks for less money and be more effective than bloated inefficient government.
The outsourcing that occured was done on the basis of cost plus no bid contracts for the likes of Halliburton, KBR, BlackWater USA, USIS, Bechtel, etc meaning no other companies could compete for these contracts. What resulted was rampant fraud, waste, and abuse. The tax payers watched as billions of dollars vanished while a Republican Congress could not care less because it was their cronies making the profits.
To add insult to injury alot of the contractors hired by BlackWater USA were ex-military meaning our tax dollars, in some cases millions of dollars, were already spent training these people. They are then lured away by the promise of a six figure salary at BlackWater USA (now Xe). Yet somehow we are to believe that privatization would save tax dollars and be more effective. It wasn’t and continues not to be.
So, why should we expect anything different than what we have now from the for-profit health insurance industry if left to their own devices? They are not going to lower premiums out of the goodness of their heart. If the private sector was working so well for Americans there would be no need for reform. Clearly it’s not working as we can all agree at the very least the concept of preexisting conditions is killing people. And, WellPoint turning in record profits while raising rates also makes no sense unless you are a shareholder or executive or a politician getting campaign contributions.